Choosing the Right Roofing Material for Your Home

Asphalt vs. Metal vs. Slate
(and Everything In-Between!)
By the Roofing Experts at Legendary Roofing and Construction
📞 Call us: 405-714-6034 📧 legendaryroofingok@gmail.com

The Great Roofing Debate: What Shingle Reigns Supreme?

Picture this: You're standing in your front yard, looking up at your house.  Birds chirp, the sun is shining, and you think, “Wow, my roof really could use some love.”

You’ve got a million questions and only one roof.  Should you go with classic asphalt?  The rugged charm of metal?  Or maybe the Rolls-Royce of roofing - slate?  Choosing the right shingles is like picking a tattoo for your house - it’s a long-term commitment, and ideally, you don’t want regrets.

Lucky for you, you’ve just stumbled upon the most informative (and moderately hilarious) guide to roofing shingles on the internet.

Roofing Material Showdown: Asphalt vs. Metal vs. Slate (and their extended family)

Let’s break down the roofing options like we’re hosting the Real Housewives of Roofing Materials.

Asphalt Shingles – The Reliable Classic

Best For: Budget-conscious homeowners who still want curb appeal.

🛠️ Types:
  • 3-Tab Asphalt: Flat, light, cheaper. Think basic cable.
  • Architectural (Dimensional) Shingles: Layered, textured, fancier. Think Netflix Premium.
  • Class 4 Impact-Resistant Shingles: Hulk-mode asphalt. Hail? 'Meh'
✅ Pros:
  • Affordable
  • Easy to install and repair
  • Comes in a kaleidoscope of colors
  • Decent lifespan (15–30 years)
  • Insurance discounts with Class 4 variants
❌ Cons:
  • Shorter lifespan than premium materials
  • Can get a little moody in extreme weather
  • Not the eco-friendliest

Composite Shingles – Asphalt’s Fancier Cousin

Best For: Homeowners who want that high-end slate or wood look, without the high-end cost.

✅ Pros:
  • Durable and lighter than real slate/wood
  • Great for aesthetic goals (read: Instagram-worthy roofs)
  • Often Class 4 impact rated
  • 30–50 year lifespan
❌ Cons:
  • More expensive than asphalt
  • Limited recyclability (Mother Nature gives it a 3/5)
🧠 Fun Fact:Composite shingles are made from a magical cocktail of asphalt, fiberglass, and polymers. Basically, they’re the Frankenstein of shingles—but in a good way.

Metal Roofing – The Cool Kid on the Block

Best For: Homeowners who want durability, energy efficiency, and the satisfying sound of rain pitter-pattering overhead.

🛠️ Types:
  • Standing Seam: Sleek and modern.
  • Metal Shingles: Looks like traditional shingles. Fool your HOA.
✅ Pros:
  • Lasts 40–70 years
  • Fire-resistant and energy-efficient
  • Great for rain and snow shedding (hello Oklahoma thunderstorms)
  • Environmentally friendly—often made from recycled materials
❌ Cons:
  • Higher upfront cost
  • Can dent (hail-sized golf balls are not ideal)
  • HOA might side-eye you unless it’s styled right

Slate Roofing – The Roof Royalty

Best For: Luxury homes, historic restorations, and people who casually use the phrase “my summer estate.”

✅ Pros:
  • Lasts 100+ years (yes, really)
  • Gorgeous and unique
  • Fireproof and extremely durable
❌ Cons:
  • Extremely heavy (your home might need structural reinforcement)
  • Very expensive
  • Not a DIY-friendly material

Tile Roofing – The Mediterranean Dream

Best For: Spanish-style homes, sun-drenched climates, and people who wear linen unironically.

✅ Pros:
  • Beautiful and timeless
  • Long-lasting (50–100 years)
  • Excellent for hot climates
❌ Cons:
  • Expensive and heavy
  • Not ideal for cold climates with freeze/thaw cycles
  • Can be fragile under pressure (like your cousin at Thanksgiving)
Material Cost 💰 Lifespan ⏳ Hail Resistance
3-Tab Asphalt$ 15–20 years Moderate
Architectural$$ 25–30 years Good (Class 4)
Composite$$$ 30–50 years Excellent
Metal$$$ 40–70 years Great
Tile$$$$ 50–100 years Moderate
Slate$$$$$
 75–150 years Excellent
Common Questions (and slightly sarcastic answers)

“Is metal roofing noisy?”  Yes. And no.  With proper insulation, it's no louder than a squirrel party on asphalt.
“Will a slate roof crush my house?”  Only if your house is made of toothpicks.  Let us evaluate your roof structure before you go full castle-mode.
“Are Class 4 shingles really worth it?”  Yes - especially in hail-prone Oklahoma.  It’s like wearing a helmet… for your house.

So... Which Roof Should You Choose?

🎯 If you’re on a budget → Architectural or 3-tab asphalt
🎯 If you want low maintenance + modern style → Metal roofing
🎯 If you’re building your forever home → Slate or composite
🎯 If your HOA is picky → Composite or architectural asphalt
🎯 If hail is your arch-nemesis → Class 4 asphalt or metal

Why Legendary Roofing and Construction is Your Roofing Expert

Here’s the deal: you’ve read the charts and now you’re realizing - this isn’t a DIY YouTube tutorial kind of job.  You need roofing experts with experience, style, and a sense of humor.

At Legendary Roofing and Construction, we don’t just slap shingles on roofs.  We guide you through the process, help you navigate insurance claims, and make sure your home is protected and beautified for decades.

👉 Visit: oklegendary.com
📞 Call:  405-714-6034
📧 Email: legendaryroofingok@gmail.com

Ready to Get a Roof as Legendary as You?
Click here to Request Your Free Roofing Consultation. Because your home deserves more than just “meh” shingles. It deserves a legendary roof.
Search